September 03, 2004

When it gets to dogs, this social networking thing has gone to far

Today I received an long 'zine email from David Weinberger, who reminded me that he had set up a neighborhood on the fashionable new geographically-based academia-powered social networking site, i-Neighbors, so I went and checked out North Berkeley, the neighborhood that I, slave to blog-fashion and still hoping that somewhere, somehow, someday, I will find out what these social networking sites are good for, had created after reading David's initial post. To my great surprise I was no longer the only member of the i-hood, quite a few other people had moved in. As I was checking out their pages, I saw that one of them had a link with his pet's name. I clicked and was taken to ... Dogster. Apparently this is old news to many, but it was the first I had heard of it, and its companion site, Catster.

On one hand this makes sense. There may even be a business model buried in there somewhere -- a lot of pet owners are fanatical about their pets, as anyone who has recently followed San Francisco politics and the battles between the dog owners vs. the Natural Areas Program can attest. And they spend a lot of money -- Americans spent 32.4 billion dollars on their pets last year, and upscale pet businesses are doing well. Or there may not be a business here -- remember the sock puppet?

Whatever the business rationale, this is nuts. Social networking for pets? Give me a break. It is a symptom, not a cause, but what does it say about what our priorities are in this country?

Nothing that sits well in my stomach.

Posted by Geodog at September 3, 2004 02:17 AM | TrackBack
Comments

My apologies, but my web hoster has turned off commenting, due to a flood of obscene spam bringing the server to its knees. I hope to have this weblog transitioned over to Wordpress in the near future, so that I can have commenting up and working again. Until then, please feel free to send me your comments via my email contact form.. Please ignore everything below this comment.

LOL! I love the way you put it, and I definately agree; this is nuts!

Posted by: Sammy on September 3, 2004 03:21 AM

Hmmmm, sounds like there might be a case of book cover judging here. Turns out Dogster was started as a humorous side project, not a business plan. My original goal was to make $500/mo in advertising to offset the vagaries of a contractor's income and perhaps use it is a promotional piece for my company.

If you explore Dogster you'll see it's not really about "social networking." What people really enjoy about it is the personal publishing. The features to dialogue with other users were actually post-launch add-ons at the bequest of a very desirous subset. In the end what motivates each user to show-off their pet ends up generating a giant grazing field for all other users to entertain themselves. Happiness is a warm puppy afterall, and a picture of one is the second best thing.

Now, however, comes the really interesting part where a fun project becomes wildly popular - 7.5 mil page views a month, 450,000 visits a month. Watch along why don't you? I definitely don't think it'll be anything to turn your nose up to.

Woof woof.

Posted by: Ted Rheingold on September 30, 2004 12:44 AM
Post a comment